Sunday, April 25, 2010

Prisoner of Stars

These days, most of the Indians planning to get married (the traditional way) seem to be "Prisoners of Stars". I call them so for their sheer over dependence on stars / astrology for taking life’s most important decision- marriage.

A typical Indian arranged marriage begins with the horoscope match, which is the first and possibly the hardest criteria to filter “good” prospective partners. Stars decide the compatibility, what the intellect suggests, comes later. Loads of dependencies follow suit- you cannot marry a partner who descends from your “Gothra”, if you are a “Dev” gan, you cannot marry a “Rakshas” gan, if you are a non-Manglik, you cannot marry a Manglik, etc. Being Manglik is a taboo, it’s like being HIV +ve, everyone runs away from marrying you :). Although perfectly normal in regular life, Mangliks risk the partner's life by transferring misfortune (if not sexually transmitted virus ;)), at times to the extent of causing an untimely death.

It would be incorrect for me to comment negative about Astrology as a science, unless I know everything about it (little knowledge is a dangerous thing, isn’t it?), but then, if it is a science, it should have a standard result. E.g. A certain set of astrological (star) positions should result in a common outcome, whoever on earth reads it, so how is it that each astrologer (guruji) reads it and comes up with his own set of results? Is there any measure to validate the exactness of an astrologer’s predictions? To me, it’s nothing more than a few blind men observing an elephant by their sense of touch- one who touches the legs, calls it a pillar, and another touching the tail, calls it a rope :).

They say the most important decisions in life should be taken by placing your head above your heart. Only your own sane intellect, and not an emotional heart can decide what is best for you. Even nature has placed our head above our heart. (But nature has also placed the stars way above our mortal heads, maybe that gives it an upper hand.)

I truly wonder how people base the most important decisions of their lives, not on what their eyes see, brain thinks and intellect suggests, but on matters they don’t even understand completely. More practical we get in this, more successful marriages we may produce.

6 comments:

  1. Are you going through the same phase?

    ReplyDelete
  2. कौस्तुभ छान लिहिले आहेस .
    पत्रिका जमणे न जमणे हे लग्न ठरवण्याचे माध्यम असावे कि असू नये, आणि एखाद्या ग्रहाच्या हातात आपल्या आयुष्याची दोरी खरच असते का, हे प्रश्न पुराव्याने' शाबित करेन' ह्या प्रकारे साबित करता येत नाहीत हे खरे आहे . शास्त्र जरी असले तरी हे ज्योतिष शास्त्र मोघम तर्हेने मांडण्यात आले आहे, एखाद्या राशीच्या व्यक्तीची सर्वसाधारण कल्पना यावी म्हणून ते मांडले गेले आहे, पत्रिका जुळवणे आणि फोटो सोबत ठेवणे, कधी कधी पत्रिका जुळत असली तरीही फोटो आवडलेला नसतो मग मुलाकडचे सांगतात कि "अहो पत्रिका जमत नाही."
    हिंदू लोकांमध्ये हि प्रथा फार पूर्वीपासून आहे, ग्रहांवर, तू म्हणल्याप्रमाणे गणांवर विश्वास , 'मांगलिक'हा समज;परत समान नाडी असेल तर विवाह अयोग्य म्हणतात इत्यादी सर्व विचारात घेतले जाते आहे आणि अजून देखील घेतले जाईलच,का म्हणशील तर आपल्या समाजाला एक प्रकारची चौकट आहे,आणि हि विचारांची चौकट तोडली तर मनाच्या कोणत्या तरी कोपऱ्यात भीती वाटते कि काहीतरी चुकत तर नाहीये न? आपल्या मुलाचे किवा मुलीचे लग्न पत्रिकेशिवाय केले तर काही वाईट घडणार नाही कशावरून? ह्या भयाला जोवर ठाम मतांची आणि मनाच्या शक्तीची साथ मिळणार नाही तोवर हे 'पत्रिका पुराण'असेच चालू राहणार.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi KA,
    you've touched a nice topic here.
    Even I'm quite curious to know how exactly this 'horoscope-matching' thingy works out.
    I've seen plenty of arranged marriages breaking up and a lot of love marriages succeeding, in spite of mis-matched stars.
    Secondly, I'm a muslim. We don't match stars. So how come so many muslim couples live successfully in spite of never matching horoscopes?
    I could say the same about Christian marriages.
    In my opinion, its all a matter of your mind and heart 'accepting' the other person.
    The stars can go find a new contellation to hang on to :D

    PS : No offence meant to people who do follow the horoscopes.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Well said Noor.
    The worst part is- they would hardly match horoscopes in the past- my own mom-dad married without a horoscope-match, and these days, hardly anyone moves ahead if they horoscope doesn't match. Nobody wants to take the onus on themselves, if anything goes wrong in a marriage, its easy to blame the stars.

    Makes me think- were our parents ahead of time in not matching the horoscopes, or do we live in a retarding society??

    ReplyDelete
  5. I feel it is an excuse too..

    Like when one does not like the boy/girl you can safely say your "jyotshi" has said the patrika's dont match..we cannot proceed.

    Simple.. no need to give any other reason which may sound offensive, it is about playing safe..

    Also for zillions of people there are just 12 zodiac signs.. do you think zillion/12 share thier fates..

    ReplyDelete